Killers of the Flower Moon Review: The True Story


Killers of the Flower Moon

Killers of the Flower Moon Review: The True Story

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Killers of the Flower Moon: A Movie Review and the True Story Behind It

Land Relocation and the Hidden Mineral Rights

Oil has made fortunes, built industries, and helped turn America into an economic powerhouse. But the story of oil in America isn’t just a story of business success. In Killers of the Flower Moon, we see a much darker side of that wealth, when members of the Osage Nation became targets because of the oil beneath their land.

It raises an uncomfortable question: what happens when the desire for wealth becomes more important than the lives and rights of other people?

I read Killers of the Flower Moon about 10 years ago, and it was very good. I wrote this post because of the Netflix series “Little House on the Prairie.” It’s also quite good, and season two is planned. While watching the show, they mentioned Kansas as where the Ingles settled, the Osage Indian tribe, and that the government was moving them off the land. I had to look that up since the original series in the 70s took place in Walnut Creek, Minnesota. The reboot takes the novels from Laura Ingalls to the actual start of the family journey. Now for the Osage indian saga.

In the 1870s, the U.S. government forcibly moved the Osage people from their ancestral home in Kansas to a territory in Oklahoma. Believing the rocky, hilly land in northeastern Oklahoma was useless for agriculture, white settlement interests left the Osage alone.

During the treaty and reassignment, under the Osage Allotment Act of 1906, tribal leaders refused to sell unless they could retain communal subsurface mineral rights, to keep the tribe together as their ancestors had lived.

See also  American Exceptionalism: How America Built Its Power

This was critical to the land-buying negotiations because the Osage would not settle unless the land were communal, not individually owned.

The relocation moved the Cherokee to Oklahoma. The US never really honored land agreements with the Native Americans; new land and treaty deals were always created as the nation grew.

Titan and the Rockefeller story

The Richest People Per Capita on Earth

In the late 1890s and early 1900s, people discovered vast oil reserves beneath the Osage reservation. Instead of selling the land or mineral rights, the tribe leased drilling rights to major oil companies and received royalties distributed through fractional shares called “headrights.” Headrights could not be bought or sold by outsiders—they could only be inherited.

With the oil boom starting in the 1920s, Oklahoma was a prime location for mineral reserves right under where the Osage settled. By 1923, they were the wealthiest people in the world, with over 30 million, which is hundreds of millions in today’s dollars. The Osage built mansions, traveled, and had nice cars; they were the super wealthy. The children attended private schools.

Systematic Exploitation & The Guardian System

Outraged by Native American wealth and operating under racial prejudice, the U.S. Congress passed a law in 1921 requiring the courts to appoint local white “guardians” for any Osage individual deemed “incompetent”—a label almost automatically applied to full-blooded tribal members.

These guardians (lawyers, bankers, and local business people) controlled Osage citizens’ money, giving them small allowances while siphoning millions for themselves through bloated fees, systemic fraud, and artificially low prices.

See also  Book Review: 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History

The “Reign of Terror” (1920s)

See how honest we were: they took their land, relocated them, and then changed the deal and laws when the original deal and laws did not favor the US government. The legal swindling quickly escalated into murder. Between 1921 and 1926, an estimated 20 to over 60 Osage individuals died under mysterious or violent circumstances in what became known as the Reign of Terror.

The wealthiest families were targeted for extinction to consolidate land rights.

  • Poisoning: to look like a sickness.
  • Point-Blank Shootings: Murdering targets in remote ravines.
  • Explosions: Detonating dynamite under homes while families slept.

One of the central masterminds was William K. Hale, a powerful local white cattleman who styled himself the “King of the Osage Hills.” Hale encouraged his nephew, Ernest Burkhart, to marry Mollie Kyle, a wealthy Osage woman. Hale then orchestrated the systematic murders of Mollie’s sisters, mother, and brother-in-law so that Ernest—and by extension Hale—would inherit their entire family estate and oil headrights. Mollie herself was being slowly poisoned before intervention occurred.

FBI Investigation

Local and state law enforcement were largely bribed, terrified, or complicit. In desperation, the Osage Tribal Council petitioned the federal government for help.

The case went to the newly formed Bureau of Investigation (later renamed the FBI), led by young J. Edgar Hoover. Hoover assigned former Texas Ranger Tom White to lead an undercover team. White’s agents went undercover as insurance salespeople, cattle buyers, and herbal doctors to gain trust and compile evidence. This was one of the FBI’s earliest cases.

See also  Daily Writing Prompt 11-Sep: Who is your favorite cartoon character?

By 1926, the team uncovered the conspiracy, leading to the conviction and imprisonment of William Hale, Ernest Burkhart, and several accomplices.

Notable Book on the Subject

The definitive modern book documenting this history is:

Killers of the Flower Moon: The Osage Murders and the Birth of the FBI, the book I read and mentioned in the opening.

The review of the book will be out Nov-22-2026

  • Author: David Grann
  • Publication Year: 2017

Overview: The author investigates the murders, the conspiracy, and the Burkhart family. The murders, conspiracy, and the Burkhart family. The book is structured into three parts:

  1. The Victims: The main family was Mollie Burkhart and the systematic elimination of her family.
  2. The Investigation: Detailing Tom White’s undercover work and the early development of the FBI.
  3. The Unsolved Cases: Grann’s own investigative research, which reveals that the conspiracy was far wider than the FBI ever acknowledged, suggesting dozens more murders went unpunished due to local complicity.

Note: David Grann’s book was adapted into a major 2023 feature film directed by Martin Scorsese, starring Lily Gladstone, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Robert De Niro.


Discover more from BeingKevin

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

5 responses to “Killers of the Flower Moon Review: The True Story”

  1. Whoa! Ok ok this sounds juicy!! I must check this out. Scorsese has never let me down but it’s the subject material. Yowza. I’ve read so much over the years about different tribes and land struggles here in the Northeast but in modern day situations (real estate and casinos). Interesting. I also didn’t
    know about a Little House reboot. I’m still mourning the departure of the original series about Half Pint and her family.

    Thank you!

    1. This was about the movie. I read the book, and it’s better than the movie; it goes deeper, of course. That review will come out next weekend. It is an amazing story. The Little House on the Prairie was very good; it surprised me. I am looking forward to season two.

  2. thomasstigwikman Avatar
    thomasstigwikman

    It is a terrible piece of history and I also saw the movie. You wrote a great review.

    1. I read the book and will post that review next, the book was better, more detailed.

      1. thomasstigwikman Avatar
        thomasstigwikman

        I am looking forward to reading the review for the book

Leave a Reply