Book Review: The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist
Authors: Radley Balko & Tucker Carrington
Rating: ★★★★★
Opening Hook
The US justice system is considered the envy of the world. The standard belief, “Innocent until proven guilty,” only goes so far once they settle on a suspect. It can be quite shocking to see from reading a book like this that the main goal is to put finality to something and move on without always looking at everything. The system, the people, and the goals do not always live up to the motto, and finality can be more important than truth.
Book Overview
This is not really a history book, but it is nonfiction. The story focuses primarily on two convicted men in Mississippi who served decades in prison, including time on death row for one of them, and were innocent. The need for speed and closure was more important than the truth. The primary focus was the state of Mississippi and its criminal justice system, but it also showed that the problems were not much different in other parts of the country.
The two men were Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks. Brewer was sentenced to death for the 1992 rape and murder of three-year-old Christine Jackson. Brooks was convicted of the 1990 rape and murder of three-year-old Courtney Smith and sentenced to life in prison. Both cases involved the same two forensic witnesses, Dr. Steven Hayne and Dr. Michael West. Their testimony helped put two innocent men behind bars while the actual killer, Justin Albert Johnson, remained free. Johnson eventually confessed to both murders, and DNA evidence connected him to the crimes.
What we think of as the coroner’s role in a death investigation is often a political position aligned with prosecution and law enforcement much more than the pursuit of truth. In Mississippi, two men in particular took advantage of that system, committed fraud, and used their positions to influence criminal investigations and convictions.
The two men were Dr. Steven Hayne, a pathologist who became Mississippi’s de facto medical examiner, and Dr. Michael West, a local dentist who presented himself as an expert in forensic odontology, particularly bite-mark identification. Hayne performed an extraordinary number of autopsies, reportedly handling the vast majority of the state’s homicide cases for years. West provided forensic opinions that helped prosecutors connect suspects to crimes.
Together, they became influential figures in Mississippi’s criminal justice system. They also fought against changes that would replace the outdated county coroner system with a more professional medical examiner system, helping preserve an arrangement that allowed questionable practices to continue.
What Worked
For me, it was a shocking story of how a system can be so abused at the expense of the life and freedom of others for expediency and personal gain.
The book did a great job of showing how the criminal justice system and things we take for certainty are not even close to perfect. Much of what we see on TV and hear about forensic science was based on questionable or unsupported scientific methods. Blood spatter patterns, shoeprint patterns, some ballistics comparisons, and even fingerprint evidence were sometimes presented with more certainty than the underlying science justified.
One particularly disturbing example was the bite-mark evidence presented by Dr. Michael West. In Kennedy Brewer’s case, West claimed that marks on Christine Jackson’s body were human bite marks and that they matched Brewer’s teeth. He made similarly damaging claims against Levon Brooks in the Courtney Smith case.
The problem was that these marks were not reliable evidence of human bites. The children’s bodies had been found in water, and the marks were consistent with damage caused by aquatic animals and postmortem changes. Yet this questionable testimony was presented to juries as scientific evidence connecting the accused men to the murders.
This is particularly troubling when you consider that bite-mark comparison has since been widely discredited as a reliable method of identifying an individual. It is a good example of how something that sounds scientific can be accepted in a courtroom without having the scientific foundation needed to support the conclusions being presented.
The history of the coroner system was another important part of the book. The position was often political, with elected officials or locally appointed individuals making decisions about deaths, investigations, and whether an autopsy would even be performed. In a state like Mississippi, where resources and professional oversight were limited, this created opportunities for serious abuses.
The book also explains the slow transition toward a professional medical examiner system, where qualified physicians and trained forensic pathologists make these decisions rather than relying on a political appointment or local connections.
It also showed how fake certifications and questionable professional credentials played a part in allowing unqualified people to make decisions and determine facts, even when the validity of their qualifications and methods was known to be questionable. Yet they were still allowed to influence a jury.
The system is built on speed and finality, and innocent until proven guilty is easily manipulated. In many cases, even with actual evidence to exonerate a person, once convicted, it is almost impossible to overturn a conviction or get a new trial.
The cases of Brewer and Brooks are perfect examples. It took years for the truth to come out. In Brewer’s case, DNA testing eventually excluded him as the perpetrator and helped identify Justin Albert Johnson. Johnson subsequently confessed to both murders. Brooks was also cleared after Johnson’s confession established that he had committed both crimes.
The work of the Innocence Project, founded in 1992 by attorneys Barry Scheck and Peter Neufeld, was particularly important in bringing these cases to light. The organization uses DNA testing and investigative work to help identify wrongful convictions and secure the release of innocent people. In Brewer’s case, DNA evidence was instrumental in establishing his innocence. Brooks was cleared through the investigation and Johnson’s confession.
It is worth remembering that DNA evidence was not available in its current form when these men were originally convicted. The development of more advanced DNA testing has since become one of the most important tools for uncovering wrongful convictions.
What Didn’t Work
There was nothing I can think of as a miss here. Very detailed accounts were given, with reviews and evidence presented that disputed the findings that police and prosecutors overlooked.
The book even went as far back as the Jim Crow era to show how this system was historically used to secure convictions, particularly against Black Americans, regardless of known mistakes or faulty evidence.
This historical context is important. Mississippi’s coroner system did not develop in a vacuum. It came out of a history in which local authorities, coroners, and law enforcement could exercise enormous power with very little independent oversight. The book illustrates how that structure could be used to protect the prevailing social order rather than establish the truth.
It also makes the point that institutional problems do not simply disappear when laws change. They can continue through established practices, personal relationships, political influence, and a reluctance to question people who have been treated as authorities for years.
Final Verdict
Rating: ★★★★★
This is a great book and very enlightening. It does not read like a novel or a typical history book, more like a detailed case study of how the criminal justice system works. What we once considered scientific ways of solving crimes were not always what was actually happening.
Finally, it brings out how DNA testing has become an important tool in identifying wrongful convictions and how many people have been saved through the work of organizations like the Innocence Project.
It will definitely open your eyes when it comes to the justice system, which is considered the envy of the world. If it does not change your opinion on the death penalty, nothing will.
After reading about Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks, you have to ask yourself a difficult question: How many innocent people have been convicted, and how many may have been executed, because the system was more interested in getting a conviction than finding the truth?

Leave a Reply